Agape Fellowship · Small Group Study

Dead to Sin, Alive to God

Union with Christ and the End of Sin’s Reign

ROMANS 6:1–14

Romans 5 ended with a sentence that invites abuse: “where sin increased, grace abounded all the more.” If that is true, a clever listener will ask the obvious question—why not sin more, so grace can abound more? Paul heard that charge in person; he mentioned it back in 3:8, where people were already slandering him with it. Chapter 6 is his answer, and it is not a retreat from grace. He does not say, “Grace is dangerous, so here are some rules.” He says the objection misunderstands what happened to a believer. A Christian is someone who has died. You cannot go on living in a country you have left by dying.

The passage moves in three steps. Verses 1–5 state the fact: through union with Christ, pictured in baptism, we died with Him and were raised with Him. Verses 6–11 explain the fact: the old self was crucified, sin’s claim on us has been settled, and Christ’s own death and resurrection set the pattern for ours. Verses 12–14 apply the fact: because this is true, stop letting sin rule, and hand yourself over to God. Notice that the first command does not appear until verse 11. Ten verses of what God has done come before a single verse of what we must do. That order is the whole theology of the chapter.

1. The Passage (ESV)

1What shall we say then? Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? 2By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it? 3Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? 4We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life. Romans 6:1–4
5For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his. 6We know that our old self was crucified with him in order that the body of sin might be brought to nothing, so that we would no longer be enslaved to sin. 7For one who has died has been set free from sin. 8Now if we have died with Christ, we believe that we will also live with him. 9We know that Christ, being raised from the dead, will never die again; death no longer has dominion over him. 10For the death he died he died to sin, once for all, but the life he lives he lives to God. 11So you also must consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus. Romans 6:5–11
12Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, to make you obey its passions. 13Do not present your members to sin as instruments for unrighteousness, but present yourselves to God as those who have been brought from death to life, and your members to God as instruments for righteousness. 14For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace. Romans 6:12–14

2. Historical and Cultural Background

The objection was a real accusation, not a hypothetical

Paul writes Romans around A.D. 57 from Corinth, to a church he has not yet visited. He is defending a gospel that had already earned him enemies. In 3:8 he says plainly that some people were charging him with teaching “Let us do evil that good may come.” The question in 6:1 is the same slander restated. The literary form Paul uses here is the diatribe, a teaching style common in the Greek philosophical schools, in which a teacher voices an imaginary opponent’s objection and then answers it. Paul uses it throughout Romans (2:1–5; 3:1–9; 9:19–20). The group should hear verse 1 in the voice of a critic, and verse 2 as Paul’s sharp reply.

Baptism in the Roman world

By the time Paul writes, baptism had been the universal entry rite of the church for roughly twenty-five years. A first-century reader would have understood it against two backgrounds. Jewish proselyte immersion marked a Gentile’s transfer into Israel; the rabbis spoke of the convert as a newborn child. And in the wider culture, the word baptizō meant to plunge, dip, or submerge—it was used of sinking ships and of dyeing cloth by immersion. The picture Paul draws in verse 4, burial and rising, assumes that physical image. Early church architecture confirms it: the baptistery at Dura-Europos in Syria (the earliest surviving church building, before A.D. 256) and later the octagonal baptisteries of Italy were built so that the candidate went down into the water and came up out of it. The eight-sided shape was chosen deliberately: the “eighth day” was the day of new creation after the seven of the old.

Slavery and manumission

Perhaps a third of the population of Rome in Paul’s day were slaves. Paul’s language in verses 6–7 and 12–14—“enslaved to sin,” “set free,” “reign,” “dominion”—would have landed on people who saw the system every day and in some cases lived inside it. One point of Roman law stands behind verse 7. A slave’s obligations ended at death; a dead man could not be summoned to serve, could not be beaten, could not be sold. Paul says the believer has died, and sin has therefore lost its legal hold. The slave market returns in verses 16–23 with the picture of a person who has changed masters.

The language of the legion

The ESV’s “instruments” in verse 13 translates hopla, which in Paul’s day meant weapons or armor far more often than tools. A Roman reader would have pictured a soldier’s kit. Paul’s point is that your eyes, hands, tongue, and mind are weapons, and the only question is which army holds them. The verb “present” in the same verse is the word used for a soldier reporting for duty and also for bringing a sacrifice to the altar; Paul will use it again in 12:1, “present your bodies as a living sacrifice.”

Historical Insight: Luther, Agricola, and the first “antinomians” The question of Romans 6:1 did not stay in the first century. In 1537 Luther’s former student and friend Johann Agricola began teaching that the law had no place in the Christian life at all, not even to expose sin, since grace alone ought to drive repentance. Luther coined a word for the position—Antinomer, “against law”—and spent three years (1537–1540) answering it in a series of public disputations at Wittenberg. The man who had taught Europe that we are justified by faith apart from works was the same man who insisted that a faith which leaves sin on the throne is no faith at all. Calvin met the same spirit in Geneva among the so-called Libertines, who argued that a Christian under grace could not sin. Both Reformers read Romans 6 as the apostle’s own refutation of the idea. Grace does not lower the demand of holiness; it supplies a new life that wants it.

3. Greek Word Studies

μὴ γένοιτο — mē genoito — “By no means!” (v. 2)
The strongest negative Greek allows, an optative wish: “may it never come to be.” Paul uses it ten times in Romans and almost always to reject a false inference from his own teaching. It is not a calm “no” but a recoil. Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it?
βαπτίζω — baptizō — “baptized” (v. 3)
To plunge, dip, or immerse. Outside the New Testament it describes a sunk ship, a drowned man, a garment dipped in dye. The point is not merely getting wet but being wholly placed into something. Paul says we were baptized into Christ and into His death. Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death?
σύμφυτοι — symphytoi — “united with” (v. 5)
Literally “grown together,” from the root for planting. It is the word for a graft that has fused with the host tree, or for two things that have grown into one organism. This is the only time it appears in the New Testament. Our union with Christ is organic, not contractual. For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his.
ὁ παλαιὸς ἄνθρωπος — ho palaios anthrōpos — “our old self” (v. 6)
Literally “the old man.” Paul uses the phrase three times (here, Eph. 4:22, Col. 3:9), each time paired with the “new man.” Given chapter 5, the “old man” is who we were in Adam—the whole person under Adam’s headship, not merely a bad component inside us. That person was crucified. We know that our old self was crucified with him in order that the body of sin might be brought to nothing.
καταργέω — katargeō — “brought to nothing” (v. 6)
To render inoperative, to put out of commission, to strip of power. It does not mean annihilated; Paul uses the same word of the law’s binding force on a widow (7:2) and of death itself being abolished at the end (1 Cor. 15:26). The “body of sin”—the body as sin’s instrument—has been decommissioned, not yet destroyed. in order that the body of sin might be brought to nothing, so that we would no longer be enslaved to sin.
δεδικαίωται — dedikaiōtai — “has been set free” (v. 7)
This is the verb dikaioō, “to justify,” the same word that carried chapters 3–5. Literally: “the one who has died has been justified from sin.” The ESV renders it “set free” because the sense here is legal release. Sin had a valid claim; death has discharged it. The perfect tense marks a settled state with ongoing effect. For one who has died has been set free from sin.
ἐφάπαξ — ephapax — “once for all” (v. 10)
Once, and never again; a single act with permanent effect. Hebrews uses the word three times for Christ’s sacrifice (7:27; 9:12; 10:10). Because His death to sin was unrepeatable, the believer’s death with Him is likewise finished. You do not die to sin daily in the sense of verse 10; you died once, in Him. For the death he died he died to sin, once for all, but the life he lives he lives to God.
λογίζεσθε — logizesthe — “consider” (v. 11)
The accounting verb from chapter 4, where Abraham’s faith was “counted” as righteousness (4:3). It means to reckon something as true because it is true, to carry it onto the ledger. It is not pretending; it is agreeing with God’s bookkeeping. This is the first imperative in Romans addressed to believers. So you also must consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus.
κυριεύω — kyrieuō — “have dominion” (vv. 9, 14)
From kyrios, “lord.” To act as master over. Paul uses it of death over Christ (v. 9) and of sin over the believer (v. 14), with the same answer in both cases: no longer. The word forms a bracket around the second half of the passage. For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace.
ὅπλα — hopla — “instruments” (v. 13)
Weapons, arms. The hoplite was the heavily armed Greek infantryman. Paul uses the word for “the armor of light” (13:12) and “the weapons of our warfare” (2 Cor. 10:4). The members of your body are armaments; they will be used in a war one way or the other. Do not present your members to sin as instruments for unrighteousness, but present yourselves to God.

4. Commentary

John MacArthur MacArthur reads chapter 6 as the necessary sequel to chapter 5: justification does not merely leave a person forgiven, it joins him to Christ, and that union changes who he is. He presses the word “know” (vv. 3, 6, 9)—Paul is reminding believers of facts, not asking them to generate an experience. On verse 6 he takes a firm position: the old self is not wounded or suppressed but dead. He rejects the popular “two natures” model in which an old nature and a new nature fight to a draw inside the Christian. The believer is a new person who still lives in unredeemed flesh and must fight the sin that remains in his body (hence “mortal body,” v. 12), but he is no longer the man he was in Adam. For MacArthur, verse 14 is a promise, not a wish: sin shall not have dominion. Baptism in verses 3–4 he understands as believer’s baptism by immersion, which signifies the union but does not create it; the spiritual reality came first by faith.
John Calvin Calvin opens his comments on this chapter with a principle he repeats throughout the Institutes: Christ cannot be divided. Whoever receives Him for justification receives Him also for sanctification; to have the one without the other would be to tear Christ in pieces. So Paul’s answer to the objector is not “you ought not sin” but “you cannot be in Christ and remain what you were.” Calvin describes the Christian life in this passage with two words that become standard Reformed vocabulary: mortification, the putting to death of the old man, and vivification, the rising of the new. Both flow from union with Christ, and both are lifelong. On baptism, Calvin holds that the sacrament is a true sign and seal of what God does, so that Paul can speak of what the sign signifies as though it happened in the sign; but the efficacy lies in Christ received by faith, not in the water. He also warns, against the Libertines of his own day, that “not under law but under grace” means freedom from the law’s curse and condemnation, never freedom from its instruction.
John Piper Piper’s summary of the passage is a phrase he has preached many times: become what you are. The indicatives of verses 1–10 come first because God’s act is the ground; the imperatives of verses 11–13 follow because God’s act is also the power. He draws attention to the word “consider” in verse 11 as the hinge: the fight against sin begins in the mind, with believing what God says is true of you before your feelings agree. He is emphatic that grace in verse 14 is not only pardon for the past but power for the present—a future grace that makes obedience possible. Piper also notes the resurrection logic: Paul grounds our holiness not only in Christ’s death but in the certainty that we “shall” be raised (v. 5). A person who knows where he is going lives differently now. On baptism, Piper reads Paul as speaking primarily of the spiritual reality of union, with water baptism as the God-appointed picture of it for those who already believe.
Martin Luther Luther, in his lectures on Romans and in the Small Catechism, finds in verse 4 a description of the whole Christian life. Baptism, he says, signifies that the old Adam in us should by daily contrition and repentance be drowned and die, and that a new man should daily come forth and arise to live before God. So for Luther, verse 6 is both finished and continuing: the old man was crucified with Christ once, and yet he is a stubborn drowner who keeps trying to surface. This is the root of his famous phrase simul iustus et peccator—at the same time righteous and a sinner. The believer is wholly righteous in Christ and still at war with sin in himself until the body is laid in the grave. Luther reads verse 14 as the great comfort of the chapter: the conscience is no longer under the law’s accusation, and precisely because it is no longer under accusation, it is finally free to hate sin and fight it. A terrified conscience cannot love God; a forgiven one can.
Where the four voices diverge Two differences are worth naming openly. First, on baptism. Luther and Calvin both baptized infants and treated the sacrament as a true sign and seal through which God acts; MacArthur and Piper baptize only professing believers and treat it as a picture of a union already accomplished by faith. All four agree that the water saves no one and that Paul’s argument rests on union with Christ, not on the rite. Second, on the old self. MacArthur stresses that the old man is dead and gone, so the believer should not think of himself as two people. Luther stresses that the old Adam keeps resurfacing and must be drowned daily. Calvin stands between them: the old man is crucified in principle and decisively, but mortification is a lifelong work. The difference is partly emphasis and partly real; a group should feel free to ask which reading best fits both verse 6 (“was crucified”) and verse 12 (“let not sin reign”). Paul seems to hold both: a finished death and an unfinished fight.
Leader’s Note The commonest misreading of this passage is to hear “consider yourselves dead to sin” as a technique—as if sin would stop if we only believed hard enough. Paul is not prescribing a mental trick. Verses 1–10 describe something that happened to the believer apart from any feeling; verse 11 tells him to agree with it. The order is: fact, then faith in the fact, then action on the fact. If someone in the group says “but I do not feel dead to sin,” the answer is that neither did the Roman Christians, which is why Paul had to tell them.

5. Cross-References

Romans 3:8
The accusation Paul answers in 6:1, already circulating against him.
Romans 5:20–21
The sentence that provokes the objection: grace abounding, grace reigning.
Galatians 2:20
“I have been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.” Paul’s personal statement of verse 6.
Colossians 2:11–13; 3:1–5
The closest parallel: buried with Him in baptism, raised with Him through faith; therefore put to death what is earthly in you.
2 Corinthians 5:14–17
“One has died for all, therefore all have died.” Union with Christ makes a new creation.
Ephesians 2:4–6
Made alive together with Christ, raised up with Him, seated with Him. Same grammar of “with.”
Hebrews 7:27; 9:12; 10:10
The three uses of ephapax, “once for all,” for Christ’s sacrifice.
1 Peter 2:24
He bore our sins “that we might die to sin and live to righteousness.” Peter’s version of verses 10–11.
Romans 12:1
“Present your bodies as a living sacrifice.” The same verb as 6:13, now applied to the whole life.
Ezekiel 36:26–27
The new heart and the Spirit who causes obedience. The Old Testament promise behind the new life of verse 4.
Romans 8:12–13
Paul will return to the fight: by the Spirit, put to death the deeds of the body.

6. Discussion Questions

  1. Paul’s gospel was accused of encouraging sin (3:8; 6:1). Has your understanding of grace ever been strong enough that someone could misunderstand it that way? If no one could ever raise that objection to the way we talk about grace, what might that tell us?
  2. Paul does not answer “shall we continue in sin?” with a rule. He answers with a fact: “we died.” Why is a fact about who you are a stronger defense against sin than a rule about what you must do?
  3. Three times Paul says “we know” or “do you not know” (vv. 3, 6, 9). What are the things he expects every Christian to know? How many of them did you know before this study?
  4. Verse 5 says we have been “grown together” with Christ, like a graft. What does it mean for your daily temptations that your union with Christ is organic rather than a contract you could break?
  5. The group heard three readings of “our old self was crucified”: dead and gone (MacArthur), drowned daily (Luther), crucified decisively but mortified over a lifetime (Calvin). Which reading fits your own experience, and which fits the text? Are those the same answer?
  6. Verse 7 literally says the one who has died has been justified from sin. How does the courtroom language of chapters 3–5 help explain why sin no longer has the right to rule a believer?
  7. “Consider yourselves dead to sin” (v. 11) uses the same accounting word as “counted to him as righteousness” (4:3). What is the difference between reckoning something true and pretending something is true? What happens when a Christian stops doing the reckoning?
  8. Verse 13 calls your body’s members weapons. Name one member—tongue, eyes, hands, feet, mind—that is most often deployed on the wrong side in your life. What would presenting it to God look like this week?
  9. “Sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace” (v. 14). Why is being under law a condition in which sin keeps its power? Why does grace break it? How would you explain this to someone who thinks grace is simply a lower standard?

7. Personal Application

Know. Write out, in your own words, what verses 3–10 say happened to you when you were joined to Christ. Keep it to facts: died with Him, buried with Him, raised with Him, old self crucified, sin’s claim discharged, death and sin no longer your master. Read the list aloud. These things are true whether or not you feel them today.

Reckon. Pick the one sin that most often makes you feel that nothing has changed. The next time it tempts you, do what verse 11 says before you do anything else: say to yourself, as a matter of record, “I died to that. I am alive to God in Christ Jesus.” This is not a magic formula. It is agreeing with the ledger. Then act.

Present. Verse 13 is a daily transaction, not a one-time decision. Each morning this week, before the day begins, present yourself to God in the words of the verse—as one brought from death to life—and name the specific members you are handing over for the day. Soldiers report for duty every morning. So do Christians.

Remember your baptism. Whether you were baptized as an infant or as a believer, the water said something about you: you went under and came up. Luther told Christians who were frightened by the devil to answer him with two words, baptizatus sum—“I am baptized.” If you have never been baptized, speak to one of the elders this week.

Memory Verse “So you also must consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus.”
— Romans 6:11 (ESV)

8. Closing Prayer

Father, we thank You that You did not answer our sin with a rule but with a death. You joined us to Your Son so completely that when He died, we died, and when He was raised, we were raised with Him. We confess that we often live as though none of that were true—as though sin still had the right to give orders, as though we were still the people we were in Adam. Forgive us for believing the old master’s lies.

Teach us to reckon what You have reckoned. When temptation comes, remind us that we have died to it, and that we are alive to You in Christ Jesus. Take our eyes, our hands, our tongues, our minds, and use them as weapons for righteousness. Where any of us is tired of the fight, show us that sin has no dominion, because we are not under law but under grace.

Make us people who walk in newness of life, so that the slander against Your grace is answered not by our arguments but by our lives. We ask it in the name of the One who died to sin once for all and lives to God. Amen.