Agape Fellowship · Small Group Study

Two Masters, Two Wages

Slaves of Sin or Slaves of Righteousness

ROMANS 6:15–23

Verse 14 ended with a sentence that invites a second objection: “you are not under law but under grace.” The first objector (6:1) asked whether we should sin so grace may abound. The second asks something subtler: if the law no longer rules us, does it matter whether we sin at all? Paul answers with a picture everyone in Rome understood—slavery. Nobody is free in the sense the objector imagines. Everyone serves a master; the only question is which one, and every master pays.

The passage runs in three movements. Verses 15–16 state the principle: you are the slave of whatever you obey. Verses 17–19 describe the transfer: you were slaves of sin, you obeyed the gospel from the heart, and now you belong to righteousness. Verses 20–23 compare the two masters by their fruit and their pay: shame and death on one side, sanctification and eternal life on the other.

1. The Passage (ESV)

15What then? Are we to sin because we are not under law but under grace? By no means! 16Do you not know that if you present yourselves to anyone as obedient slaves, you are slaves of the one whom you obey, either of sin, which leads to death, or of obedience, which leads to righteousness? 17But thanks be to God, that you who were once slaves of sin have become obedient from the heart to the standard of teaching to which you were committed, 18and, having been set free from sin, have become slaves of righteousness. Romans 6:15–18
19I am speaking in human terms, because of your natural limitations. For just as you once presented your members as slaves to impurity and to lawlessness leading to more lawlessness, so now present your members as slaves to righteousness leading to sanctification. 20For when you were slaves of sin, you were free in regard to righteousness. 21But what fruit were you getting at that time from the things of which you are now ashamed? For the end of those things is death. 22But now that you have been set free from sin and have become slaves of God, the fruit you get leads to sanctification and its end, eternal life. 23For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. Romans 6:19–23

2. Historical and Cultural Background

Slavery in Paul’s Rome

Estimates put the slave population of Italy in the first century at somewhere between a quarter and a third of all people. Slaves were not a race or a caste; they were prisoners of war, children of slaves, debtors, and the abandoned. A slave could be a field hand, a secretary, a physician, or the manager of an estate. What all of them shared was the legal fact that they were owned: their bodies, their labor, and their time belonged to someone else. When Paul says “slaves of sin” and “slaves of righteousness,” his readers did not hear a metaphor for employment. They heard ownership.

Paul knows the picture is blunt. Verse 19 apologizes for it: “I am speaking in human terms, because of your natural limitations.” He is saying that the slave market is too crude to describe what it means to belong to God, but it is the clearest picture available, and he uses it because the Romans were slow to understand.

Manumission and the change of masters

Roman slaves could be freed, and often were; freedmen formed a large class in the city, and the Roman church probably included many. Verse 18 pictures manumission—“having been set free from sin”—but with a twist. Paul does not say the freed slave became his own master. He says he became the slave of a new one. In Roman law, a freedman still owed his former owner certain duties and took his name; Paul inverts this, saying we owe the new master everything, because the old master paid only in death.

Wages and the soldier’s pay

The word for “wages” in verse 23 (opsōnia) is the word for a soldier’s ration-money, the regular pay that kept a legionary fed. Rome had tens of thousands of soldiers on the payroll. Paul says sin pays its soldiers on schedule and in full, and the currency is death. The contrast is pointed: on the other side is not a wage at all but a charisma, a free gift. Sin pays what is earned; God gives what is not.

Historical Insight: The “standard of teaching” Verse 17 says the Romans were “committed” to a “standard of teaching” (typos didachēs). The phrase hints that by the late 50s there was already a recognizable body of apostolic instruction handed to converts, probably at baptism. Within a few decades this would take written form: the Didache (“The Teaching”), discovered in Constantinople in 1873 and dated to the late first century, opens with “There are two ways, one of life and one of death”—a frame very close to Paul’s two masters here. The early church did not treat conversion as a private feeling. A person was handed over to a pattern of teaching, and the pattern shaped the life.

3. Greek Word Studies

δοῦλος — doulos — “slave” (vv. 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22)
Not “servant” in the sense of hired help, but one who is owned. Paul calls himself a doulos of Christ in the first verse of the letter (1:1). The word appears six times in these nine verses. you are slaves of the one whom you obey, either of sin, which leads to death, or of obedience
παρίστημι — paristēmi — “present” (vv. 16, 19)
To place at someone’s disposal; used of a soldier reporting for duty and of a sacrifice brought to the altar. The same verb as 6:13 and 12:1. Paul’s point: you have always been presenting yourself to someone. if you present yourselves to anyone as obedient slaves, you are slaves of the one whom you obey
τύπος διδαχῆς — typos didachēs — “standard of teaching” (v. 17)
Typos is a mold, a stamp, a pattern into which something is pressed. The Romans were not handed teaching; they were handed to the teaching, as metal is handed to a mold, and shaped by it. have become obedient from the heart to the standard of teaching to which you were committed
ἁγιασμός — hagiasmos — “sanctification” (vv. 19, 22)
The process of being made holy, set apart for God. The noun ends in -mos, which in Greek marks an action in progress rather than a finished state. Justification is a verdict; sanctification is a direction of travel. so now present your members as slaves to righteousness leading to sanctification
ὀψώνια — opsōnia — “wages” (v. 23)
A soldier’s pay, originally his allowance for provisions. It is earned, owed, and paid on time. Sin is a master who never misses payday. For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life
χάρισμα — charisma — “free gift” (v. 23)
From charis, grace. A gift that is pure grace, given without regard to desert. Paul used the same word five times in 5:15–16. Set beside opsōnia, the contrast is the whole gospel in one verse: one side earns, the other receives. but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord

4. Commentary

John MacArthur MacArthur hears in verse 15 the objection of the antinomian, who thinks grace makes obedience optional, and he treats Paul’s answer as decisive for the doctrine of assurance. Verse 16 states a law of human nature: no one is a free agent; obedience reveals ownership. He draws the pastoral conclusion sharply—a person who habitually presents himself to sin is showing whose slave he is, whatever he professes. Verse 17 is for him the clearest New Testament description of true conversion: obedience “from the heart,” not external conformity, to a definite body of apostolic doctrine. He stresses the past tense of “were once slaves of sin”: for the believer, that bondage is over, and the new slavery is not a burden but the only true freedom, since it is the freedom to be what God made us to be.
John Calvin Calvin notes that Paul repeats his “By no means!” because the enemies of grace never tire of the same charge. His answer to the question “are we to sin?” is that it misunderstands freedom. Fallen man imagines freedom as the absence of a master; Scripture knows of no such state. Calvin reads verse 19 as a confession of the weakness of all language about God—Paul stoops to the slave market because the Romans could not bear anything higher. On verses 20–21 he draws a hard line: the unregenerate are “free in regard to righteousness,” which is to say wholly incapable of it, and the fruit of that life is shame now and death at the end. He insists that eternal life in verse 23 is called a gift and not a wage even for the believer, so that no one who has borne fruit should imagine he has earned anything.
John Piper Piper’s emphasis is on the words “from the heart” in verse 17. The new slavery is not grudging; it is the obedience of a heart that has been changed, which is why Paul gives thanks for it. He presses the contrast of fruit in verses 21–22: sin produces things you will eventually be ashamed of, while righteousness produces holiness that ends in life. The question for every temptation is therefore “where does this lead?”—and faith is believing God’s answer over sin’s advertisement. He highlights verse 23 as a summary of the gospel in a single sentence and warns against softening “death” into something less than eternal separation from God. For Piper, the free gift and the fight for holiness are not in tension: grace gives the gift, and grace gives the desire to serve the Giver.
Martin Luther Luther, who had spent years trying to earn what verse 23 calls a free gift, reads this passage as a liberation. The Christian is free from the law as a way of salvation; he is not free from obedience, because he has a new Lord. In the Freedom of a Christian he put the two sides together: a Christian is a free lord of all, subject to none; a Christian is a dutiful servant of all, subject to all. Both are true because of union with Christ. He warns from verse 16 that those who use grace as permission are revealing they never had it; grace does not sit idle in the heart. On verse 23, Luther is blunt: death is not merely the body in the grave but the wrath of God, and sin earns it fairly. The gift of life is given, and it is given in Christ Jesus—the words that keep the gift from ever becoming a wage.
Where the four voices diverge The four agree almost entirely on this passage. The one difference is emphasis on what obedience proves. MacArthur draws the pastoral line hardest: persistent disobedience is evidence of an unconverted heart, and churches should say so. Luther, who knew the terrified conscience from the inside, is more careful that believers not read every failure as proof of damnation; the Christian remains a sinner who is fighting, not a slave who has returned. Calvin and Piper would say both are right, applied to different people: the complacent need MacArthur, the despairing need Luther. A group should ask which of the two its own members need.
Leader’s Note Modern readers often resist the slavery language and want to say Christians are “free.” Paul agrees they are free—from sin (v. 18, 22). But he never says they are autonomous. Help the group see that “slave of God” is a title of honor in Scripture (Moses, David, Paul all bear it) and that the alternative is not independence but a crueler master.

5. Cross-References

John 8:34–36
“Everyone who practices sin is a slave to sin… if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.”
Romans 1:1
Paul, a slave of Christ Jesus. The title he gives himself before any other.
1 Corinthians 6:19–20; 7:22–23
“You were bought with a price.” The freedman of the Lord is Christ’s slave.
Galatians 5:13
Freedom is not an opportunity for the flesh but for serving one another.
1 Peter 2:16
Live as free people, not using freedom as a cover for evil, but as servants of God.
Matthew 6:24
No one can serve two masters.
James 1:14–15
Desire conceives sin; sin, when full grown, brings forth death. The same wage.
Romans 5:15–17
The charisma, the free gift, in its first appearance.

6. Discussion Questions

  1. Verse 15 raises a second objection, different from 6:1. What is the difference between “shall we sin so grace abounds?” and “shall we sin since we are not under law?” Why does Paul give the same answer to both?
  2. “You are slaves of the one whom you obey” (v. 16). Is this a command or a description? What does it imply about the idea of a person who belongs to no master?
  3. Paul gives thanks in verse 17 that the Romans obeyed “from the heart.” Why is heart-obedience something to thank God for rather than something to congratulate the Romans on?
  4. Verse 19 says Paul is “speaking in human terms” because of their limitations. Where does the slavery picture fall short of describing what it means to belong to God?
  5. Verse 21 asks what fruit the old life produced. Paul expects the answer “things of which you are now ashamed.” Why is shame about the past a sign of health rather than a sign of condemnation?
  6. Sin pays wages; God gives a gift. If eternal life is a gift, why does Paul still speak of “fruit” and “sanctification” as the path to it (v. 22)? How are those two ideas held together without contradiction?
  7. Luther and MacArthur apply this passage differently to the struggling Christian. Which application does our group need more right now, and why?

7. Personal Application

Name your master. Verse 16 says obedience reveals ownership. Look at the last week and ask: what did I obey? Not what did I believe, but what did I do when it was hard? Write it down. If the answer is uncomfortable, that is the passage doing its work.

Follow the fruit. Take one habitual sin and ask verse 21’s question: what fruit have I gotten from this? Trace it to the end. Then take one habit of obedience and do the same. Paul expects the comparison to be lopsided.

Give thanks for your obedience. Paul thanks God that the Romans obeyed (v. 17). If you have obeyed God this week in anything, do not take the credit. Thank Him. That single habit protects the heart from both pride and despair.

Memory Verse “For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.”
— Romans 6:23 (ESV)

8. Closing Prayer

Lord, we confess that we were slaves of sin, and that we served that master willingly. We thank You that You did not leave us there. You bought us, You freed us, and You made us Your own. We bring You no wages, because we have earned nothing but death; we hold out our hands for the gift, eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.

Make our obedience come from the heart. Show us the fruit of the things we are tempted by, and show us the fruit of serving You, so that we choose with open eyes. Where any of us has grown ashamed of the past, turn that shame into gratitude. Where any of us has grown careless with grace, wake us up. We are Yours. Amen.